What are the most common problems with hot water tanks?

A traditional tank-style water heater is fairly simple, but several things can go wrong as the unit ages. Some problems are minor, such as a thermostat setting that needs adjustment. Others, including leaking tanks, failed heating elements, burner problems or excessive corrosion, may require professional repair or replacement.

Here are some of the most common hot water tank problems homeowners experience.

Water heater is not producing hot water

If you suddenly have no hot water at all, the cause depends partly on whether you have a gas or electric water heater.

With an electric water heater, common causes include:

  • A tripped circuit breaker
  • A failed heating element
  • A bad thermostat
  • Loose or damaged wiring

With a gas water heater, possible causes include:

  • A pilot light that has gone out
  • A failed igniter
  • A thermocouple or flame-sensing problem
  • A gas valve problem
  • An interruption in the gas supply

If the tank is full of cold water and never heats, the heating system itself needs to be checked.

The water in the tank is not enough

If you still have hot water but seem to run out much faster than you used to, several things could be happening. The water heater may have a failed heating element, a thermostat problem or sediment buildup inside the tank. It is also possible that your household’s hot water demand has increased beyond what the tank can supply. An older water heater may also recover more slowly than it once did.

Water takes too long to heat

A water heater that takes unusually long to recover after a shower or other heavy use may have a heating problem. In an electric tank, one of the heating elements may have failed. In a gas unit, the burner may not be operating correctly.

Sediment buildup can also reduce heat transfer and make the water heater work harder to bring the tank back up to temperature.

Hot water is too hot

Water that suddenly becomes much hotter than normal can indicate a thermostat problem. The thermostat may be set too high or may no longer be controlling the water temperature correctly. Excessively hot water is more than an inconvenience. It can create a scalding hazard, especially for children and older adults. If adjusting the thermostat does not correct the problem, the water heater should be inspected.

The water temperature keeps changing

If your water is hot one minute and lukewarm the next, the heater may not be maintaining a consistent temperature.

Possible causes include:

  • A failing thermostat
  • A bad heating element
  • Sediment buildup
  • A burner problem
  • A dip tube problem
  • Heavy simultaneous hot water use

Inconsistent temperature can be especially noticeable during showers.

The water heater is leaking

A leaking water heater should never be ignored. The source of the leak matters.

Water may be coming from:

  • A pipe connection
  • The drain valve
  • The temperature and pressure relief valve
  • The top of the tank
  • The bottom of the tank itself

Some leaks can be repaired. If the tank itself has corroded and is leaking, however, the water heater will usually need to be replaced.

Water is leaking from the temperature and pressure relief valve

The temperature and pressure relief valve, often called the T&P valve, is an important safety device. It is designed to release water if temperature or pressure inside the tank becomes excessive.

A dripping or leaking T&P valve may indicate:

  • Excessive water pressure
  • Excessive water temperature
  • Thermal expansion
  • A failing relief valve

Do not plug, cap or disable this valve. If it is leaking repeatedly, the cause should be diagnosed.

The hot water looks rusty or discolored

Rusty or brown hot water may indicate corrosion inside the water heater or plumbing system. Tank-style water heaters contain an anode rod designed to help protect the tank from corrosion. As the water heater ages, the anode rod can deteriorate. If corrosion progresses far enough, the tank itself can eventually begin to rust. Discolored water that appears only on the hot-water side can be an important clue that the water heater is involved.

The hot water smells bad

Hot water can sometimes develop an unpleasant sulfur or rotten-egg smell. This is often related to bacteria in the tank reacting with the anode rod and naturally occurring compounds in the water. The problem may be more noticeable when the water heater has sat unused for a period of time. A technician can determine whether the water heater needs to be flushed, disinfected or serviced in another way.

The water heater makes popping or rumbling noises

Popping, cracking or rumbling noises often come from sediment accumulating at the bottom of the tank. Minerals in the water can settle over time and form a layer beneath the water. As the burner or heating element heats the tank, water trapped within the sediment can boil and create popping or rumbling sounds.

Heavy sediment buildup can reduce efficiency and contribute to premature tank wear.

The water heater makes a hissing sound

A hissing or sizzling sound can have several possible causes.

In an electric water heater, sediment may be covering a heating element. In other cases, water may be dripping onto a hot component. The source of the sound should be identified, especially if you also notice leaking water.

The pilot light keeps going out

Older gas water heaters may use a standing pilot light.

If the pilot repeatedly goes out, possible causes include:

  • A dirty pilot assembly
  • A bad thermocouple
  • A gas control problem
  • Drafts
  • Venting problems

Repeatedly relighting the pilot without figuring out why it keeps going out is not a permanent solution.

The burner will not stay lit

A gas water heater may ignite normally and then shut the burner off unexpectedly. Possible causes include problems with the thermocouple, flame sensor, gas control valve, burner assembly or venting system. Because these components involve gas combustion and safety controls, they should be properly diagnosed.

The circuit breaker keeps tripping

If an electric water heater repeatedly trips its breaker, do not continue resetting it.

Possible causes include:

  • A failed heating element
  • Damaged wiring
  • A thermostat problem
  • An electrical short

A breaker that repeatedly trips is indicating an electrical fault that needs attention.

The tank is producing less hot water as it gets older

Water heaters gradually wear out.

Sediment buildup, deteriorating heating components, corrosion and normal aging can all reduce performance. If your water heater is older and you are experiencing several problems at once, replacement may make more sense than continuing to repair individual components.

How do you know whether to repair or replace a hot water tank?

The answer depends on the age of the water heater, the condition of the tank, the cost of the repair and the type of failure. A relatively new water heater with a bad thermostat or heating element may be worth repairing. An older tank that is leaking because of internal corrosion usually needs to be replaced. The condition of the tank itself is often the deciding factor.

Need help with a hot water tank problem?

If your water heater is leaking, producing too little hot water, making unusual noises, taking too long to heat or not producing hot water at all, Roberts Brothers Comfort can inspect the system, identify the problem and recommend the appropriate repair or replacement.

Keith Murphy

Troy, OH

Great company called them at 10am. By 3pm they had the heat back on

Kathy Zimmerman

Troy, OH

We appreciate Roberts Brothers so much. Any time we have needed them, their response has been immediate. They keep us informed if parts have to be ordered and are here as soon as the parts arrive. Their quality of work is excellent. We feel confident that we can always depend on them and highly recommend them.
Heather Monroe

Piqua, OH

I was unable to get ahold of the service I had previously used. Roberts Brothers were recommended by two different people. They were prompt and solved my problem quickly. I will most definitely call them 1st in the future.

Megan Peltier

Piqua, OH

Our AC unit broke down on a Friday before Labor Day. I called Roberts Brothers that Friday and they were out there the same day. They ordered the unit we agreed on and had it installed the next business day. In the meantime, they provided a temporary AC unit we used inside the home. This was a blessing to us! The crew was nice and kept us in the loop as the installation was going on.

Tim Francis

Troy, OH

The owner was very courteous, professional and came out and helped me the day after Christmas. Very TRUSTWORTHY! Replaced my worn out part for $1,230 less than a quote from elsewhere for the same exact part. I would highly recommend you use them!

After hours & weekend service available

Use this form to contact us after hours

Preventative HVAC Maintenance Plans Available

For all furnace and AC systems