What are the first signs of a water heater going bad?

Water heaters usually give some warning before they fail completely. The first signs can be easy to overlook, especially if the unit is still producing hot water. But changes in temperature, noise, water quality or leaking can all indicate that the tank or one of its components is starting to wear out.

You are running out of hot water faster

One of the first signs of trouble is a noticeable drop in hot water capacity. You may find that showers turn cold sooner, the tank takes longer to recover, or the water never gets as hot as it used to. Possible causes include sediment buildup, a failing heating element, thermostat problems or an aging burner system.

The water heater is making new noises

Popping, rumbling or cracking sounds often point to sediment buildup at the bottom of the tank. As minerals collect inside the tank, they can interfere with normal heating and make the water heater work harder. A little noise does not always mean the tank is about to fail, but a sudden increase in noise is worth checking.

You see moisture or water around the tank

Any unexplained water around the base of the water heater deserves attention. The leak may be coming from a valve, pipe connection or fitting, which may be repairable. If the tank itself is leaking because of internal corrosion, however, the water heater will usually need to be replaced.

The hot water looks rusty or discolored

Rusty or brown water from the hot side can be a sign of corrosion inside the water heater. It may also indicate that the anode rod has deteriorated and is no longer protecting the tank effectively. If the discoloration is only present when you use hot water, the water heater is more likely to be involved.

The water temperature keeps changing

Hot water that swings between very hot, lukewarm and cold can indicate a thermostat, heating element or burner problem. Inconsistent temperature can also develop as a water heater ages and loses the ability to heat the tank evenly.

The tank is showing visible corrosion

Rust around fittings, seams, valves or the bottom of the tank is another warning sign. Surface rust does not always mean immediate failure, but corrosion on an older water heater should not be ignored. Once the tank itself begins to corrode through, it cannot be permanently repaired.

The water heater is getting old

Age alone is not proof that a water heater is failing, but an older unit deserves closer attention when other symptoms begin appearing. If an aging water heater is also leaking, making noise or producing less hot water, replacement may make more sense than continuing to repair individual parts.

When should you have it checked?

Have the water heater inspected if you notice reduced hot water, new noises, corrosion, inconsistent temperatures or any sign of leaking. Catching a problem early can sometimes mean a simple repair instead of dealing with a complete loss of hot water or a major leak.

Need help with a water heater that may be failing?

Roberts Brothers Comfort can inspect your water heater, determine whether the problem can be repaired and let you know when replacement is the better option. Call us at 937-909-3663 for help with your water heater or any indoor plumbing problem. We service homes across the area from both our Piqua and St. Paris offices.

Ryan Wallace

Troy, OH

Always great service, communication and response time. A quality, reliable company that we trust with all of our heating and cooling needs!

Stormy Nguyen

Piqua, OH

New customer. Called in and got a same day service appointment & was very happy with that. Zhane came out and did an amazing job throughly checking everything out and gave a great report to myself and my husband. Lastly, I really appreciated the fact that he wore shoe covered in our home.

Jan Palmer

Piqua, OH

Jim and I cannot be happier with Roberts Bros. Comfort!! We had a complete new HVAC system installed. Brad is professional, genuine, knowledgeable and fair… trustworthy! Gordon, Clay and Phil were amazing!! Again, professional, pleasant, knowledgeable, very clean, quiet and prompt!!  If we could give 10 stars we would!  Highly recommend this company!!

John Shellhaas

Troy, OH

Roberts Brothers Comfort did a great job. They came in and knocked the installation out! I highly recommend Roberts Brothers Comfort for your heating and/or AC work!

Kathy Zimmerman

Troy, OH

We appreciate Roberts Brothers so much. Any time we have needed them, their response has been immediate. They keep us informed if parts have to be ordered and are here as soon as the parts arrive. Their quality of work is excellent. We feel confident that we can always depend on them and highly recommend them.

After hours & weekend service available

Use this form to contact us after hours

Preventative HVAC Maintenance Plans Available

For all furnace and AC systems