How to diagnose a bad sump pump

A bad sump pump usually gives you some warning before it fails completely. Common signs include unusual noises, frequent cycling, failure to turn on, water remaining in the pit or a pump that runs but does not actually move water.

You can check several basic things safely before assuming the pump itself is bad.

Make sure the pump has power

Start by confirming that the sump pump is plugged in and that the circuit breaker has not tripped. If the pump is connected to a GFCI outlet, check whether the outlet has tripped and needs to be reset.

If the breaker or outlet trips again after being reset, stop there. Repeated electrical trips can indicate a wiring, motor or pump problem that should be inspected.

Test the float switch

The float switch tells the pump when to turn on and off. If it gets stuck, tangled or blocked by debris, the pump may not run even if the motor itself is still good.

Make sure the float can move freely inside the pit. If the pump starts when the float is raised, the switch may have been obstructed rather than failed.

Listen to what the pump is doing

A healthy sump pump should start smoothly and move water out of the pit without excessive noise. Grinding, rattling, humming or buzzing can indicate a damaged impeller, worn motor or obstruction inside the pump.

A pump that hums but does not move water may be clogged, jammed or failing internally.

Check whether water is actually leaving the pit

If the pump runs but the water level does not drop, the problem may not be the pump itself. A clogged or frozen discharge line, stuck check valve or blocked outlet can prevent water from leaving the system.

Watch the water level during a test cycle. If the pump sounds normal but the pit stays full, the discharge system needs to be checked.

Look for frequent or continuous cycling

A pump that turns on and off constantly may have a float problem, check valve issue or improperly sized pit. Continuous running can also happen when groundwater is entering faster than the pump can remove it.

Frequent cycling puts extra wear on the motor and can shorten pump life, so repeated on-and-off operation should not be ignored.

Test the pump with water

If the pit is dry, you can carefully add enough water to raise the float and activate the pump. The pump should turn on, remove the water and shut off after the level drops.

If it does not start, struggles to move water or continues running after the pit is nearly empty, the pump or one of its controls may be failing.

When should you replace the sump pump?

Replacement may be the better option if the pump is old, unreliable, noisy, repeatedly clogs or no longer moves water effectively. A sump pump that has already failed during heavy rain is especially worth evaluating before the next storm.

Roberts Brothers Comfort can test your sump pump, diagnose the cause of the problem and recommend repair or replacement if needed. Call us at 937-909-3663 for help with your water heater or any indoor plumbing problem. We service homes across the area from both our Piqua and St. Paris offices.

Lisa Tullis

Troy, OH

Our furnace went out during a very cold snap. A company I was using could not come for 3 days. Roberts came same day. We ended up having to replace but they did a great job start to finish.

Heather Rannells

Troy, OH

Brad and Stas were friendly and knowledgeable. They got the job done quickly and the problem fixed. Thank you and well done, guys!

Kay Ward

Piqua, OH

Roberts Brothers Comfort installed a Mitsubishi mini-split system in my home this week. I have absolutely zero complaints with this company and the service that was provided to me. I never felt pressured during the initial visit with Brad at my home, he was patient and took the time to answer all of my many questions. My new system was installed in the quoted timeframe. The installers Phil & Stas worked diligently each day, provided periodic updates during the day as I was unable to be home due to work, and also walked me through each day’s progress when I returned home in the afternoon. The system is working great and Roberts Brothers Comfort really made the entire process painless. I would highly recommend this company.

Mike McDonald

Piqua, OH

Always great service! Very professional and courteous!! We love Robert Brothers HVAC!

Megan Peltier

Piqua, OH

Our AC unit broke down on a Friday before Labor Day. I called Roberts Brothers that Friday and they were out there the same day. They ordered the unit we agreed on and had it installed the next business day. In the meantime, they provided a temporary AC unit we used inside the home. This was a blessing to us! The crew was nice and kept us in the loop as the installation was going on.

After hours & weekend service available

Use this form to contact us after hours

Preventative HVAC Maintenance Plans Available

For all furnace and AC systems