How common is it for a water heater to burst?

A water heater bursting is not especially common, but it can happen, particularly with an older or badly corroded tank.

Most water heaters do not suddenly explode without warning. More often, the tank begins to weaken over time because of corrosion, excessive pressure, sediment buildup or failure of an important safety component. In many cases, there are warning signs before a serious leak or rupture occurs.

Why would a water heater burst?

One of the most common causes is corrosion inside the tank. Tank-style water heaters contain an anode rod that helps protect the steel tank from rusting. As the water heater ages, that rod gradually deteriorates. Eventually, corrosion can begin attacking the tank itself. Once the tank wall becomes weak enough, it can begin leaking or fail more dramatically.

Excessive pressure can also be a problem

Water expands as it heats. Normally, your plumbing system and the water heater’s safety controls manage that pressure. If pressure inside the tank becomes excessive, the temperature and pressure relief valve, commonly called the T&P valve, is designed to release it. A malfunctioning or blocked relief valve can create a much more serious situation. Never plug, cap or disable a leaking T&P valve. If it is releasing water repeatedly, the cause should be investigated.

Sediment can contribute to tank damage

Minerals can settle at the bottom of a water heater and create a layer of sediment. Heavy sediment buildup can make the water heater work harder and can cause popping or rumbling noises as the water heats. Over time, that extra heat and stress can contribute to wear on the tank.

Sediment alone does not mean the tank is about to burst, but it can be one factor that shortens the life of the water heater.

Are there warning signs before a water heater fails?

Often, yes. Watch for:

  • Water collecting around the bottom of the tank
  • Rust or corrosion on the tank or fittings
  • Rusty or discolored hot water
  • Popping or rumbling noises
  • Water leaking from fittings or valves
  • A T&P valve that repeatedly releases water
  • A noticeable decline in hot water performance

A small leak around an older tank can turn into a much larger one, so it is best not to wait until water is covering the floor.

What should you do if the tank starts leaking badly?

If a water heater suddenly begins releasing a large amount of water, shut off the water supply to the tank if you can do so safely. For an electric water heater, power should also be shut off at the breaker. For a gas water heater, follow the manufacturer’s shutdown instructions or contact a professional if you are unsure how to shut it down safely. Then arrange for service as soon as possible.

Should an old water heater be replaced before it bursts?

Not every older water heater needs immediate replacement, but age becomes increasingly important when the tank begins showing signs of corrosion or leakage. A leaking tank itself generally cannot be repaired. Once the steel tank has corroded through, replacement is usually the practical solution.

Worried about your water heater bursting?

A catastrophic water heater rupture is uncommon, but leaking, corrosion, excessive pressure and other warning signs should not be ignored. Roberts Brothers Comfort can inspect your hot water tank, determine whether it can be repaired safely and let you know when replacement is the better option. Call us at 937-909-3663 for help with your water heater or any indoor plumbing problem. We service homes across the area from both our Piqua and St. Paris offices.

Ryan Hochwalt

Troy, OH

Fast reliable service, great communication and reasonable price. Tech was very nice and knowledgeable, will use them again. Fixed my issue and checked to make sure everything else was in good shape.
Brian Murphy

Troy, OH

We had an A/C unit that was failing on the hottest day of the year and Brad was able to find a replacement and Roberts Brothers techs got it installed the next morning.

Heather Rannells

Troy, OH

Brad and Stas were friendly and knowledgeable. They got the job done quickly and the problem fixed. Thank you and well done, guys!

Abigail Wise

Troy, OH

Roberts Brothers Comfort provides truly first class, five star service! We could not be more happy with the work that Robert’s brothers did. Our furnace broke unexpectedly so we were without heat. We called Robert’s brothers and they fit us in same day for a consultation. They were able to work very very quickly to replace our furnace, they did a full cleaning and sanitation of our heating duct system, and they restored our heat in record time! From the initial conversation with Michelle on the phone to troubleshoot and make an appointment, to speaking with Brad for an initial visit, to the actual furnace repair cleaning and heat restoration, everything was top-notch in regards to service! Everyone at Roberts Brothers is so incredibly kind and efficient in the service that they provide. Their HVAC technicians Phil, Clay, and Stas were so kind, professional, tidy, and efficient! We genuinely could not be more happy with the service that they gave us! They are definitely in the right line of work because they are excellent! I would recommend them to anyone I know or don’t know!

Rebecca Roll

Piqua, OH

I love the whole team at Roberts Brothers. They have repaired my existing system. Helped me replace and finance a broken system. Install gas lines for gas dryer and stove. Their whole team from Michelle in the office the Phil and the guys who show up to help every time are the best. Reasonable and trustworthy. Highly recommend.

After hours & weekend service available

Use this form to contact us after hours

Preventative HVAC Maintenance Plans Available

For all furnace and AC systems